Novel 204: Mary E. Mann, In Summer Shade (1893)

 
Daniel Maclise, Yes or No

Daniel Maclise, Yes or No

 

A virtuous but self-willed young lady with a discreditable family attracts the love of both a faithful farmer and a haughty aristocrat.


Here is a another novel by Mann, for whom see Novels 016 and 154. A priggish clergyman character is especially well done.

“In very few recent novels will there be found anything approaching its grasp of character and firmness of touch.  The writer looks at life with a very straight eye.  She certainly does not err on the side of idealizing character, and is not at all averse to laughing at those with whom she is on friendly terms. . . .  Her characters are not made of ink and paper, but of flesh and blood, and her book has no flimsiness in either its thought or its workmanship.” Bookman, February 1893

For the author it “has clearly been recreation as well as work, and it happens not unnaturally that the reader as well as the writer is recreated. . . .  It has impulse, movement, sprightliness, life.” Academy, March 4, 1893

Download this week’s novel:

v.1 http://access.bl.uk/item/viewer/ark:/81055/vdc_00000004DED4#?c=0&m=0&s=0&cv=6&xywh=513%2C666%2C3426%2C2083

v.2 http://access.bl.uk/item/viewer/ark:/81055/vdc_00000004DEDA#?c=0&m=0&s=0&cv=6&xywh=-325%2C-1%2C3227%2C1963

v.3 http://access.bl.uk/item/viewer/ark:/81055/vdc_00000004DEE0#?c=0&m=0&s=0&cv=6&xywh=-362%2C-1%2C3162%2C1923



Novel 198: Margaret Agnes Paul, Uncle Ralph (1858)

 
Richard Buckner, Bust Study of an Unknown Young Girl

Richard Buckner, Bust Study of an Unknown Young Girl


An orphan girl’s unusual self-possession alienates the uncle who adopts her.


Here is another novel by Paul (see Novels 025, 136), with all its author’s usual merits.

One of the most pleasing tales of domestic life that we have seen for many a day.” Literary Gazette, February 13, 1858

“A readable little story” with some “well drawn” characters. Athenaeum, March 27, 1858

Download this week’s novel:

http://solo.bodleian.ox.ac.uk/permalink/f/89vilt/oxfaleph014181085
(Warning: text begins on page 23, after some black pages, and blurred pages, and pictures of a librarian’s pink-gloved hand)

 

Novel 194: Charles Gibbon, What Will the World Say? (1875)

 
Charles Burton Barber, An Elegantly Dressed Horsewoman Jumping Over a Gate

Charles Burton Barber, An Elegantly Dressed Horsewoman Jumping Over a Gate

 

In Scotland, a self-made millionaire’s daughter and niece fall in love with the same man.


Charles Gibbon (1843-1890) wrote some 30 novels beginning in 1864.  This one features, in addition to some stock Victorian-novel figures (the ill-bred, wealthy industrialist, the self-sacrificing virtuous young lady, the young lover enraged by a misunderstanding) two carefully delineated and thoroughly interesting main characters.

Gibbon “has imagined the extraordinary fluctuations of” a main character’s “feelings . . . with remarkable felicity, and has drawn them with great skill. . . .  It is an excellent and a very rare thing when the interest of a novel decidedly increases as it goes on.” Academy, September 9, 1875

The novel “should do much to give him a high place among delineators of character. . . .  Besides containing several very masterly studies, it is full of humour, of quaint, wise, remark, and may be taken as a reliable picture of life in the district where the scene is laid.” Spectator, October 2, 1875

Download this week’s novel:

http://solo.bodleian.ox.ac.uk/permalink/f/89vilt/oxfaleph014735908
(Right-click (or control-click, if you have a Mac) on the “view digitized copy” links to download the novel’s three volumes in pdf form)

Novel 191: Frances Milton Trollope, The Barnabys in America (1843)

 
Frederick Daniel Hardy, Two Children Studying with a Globe and Piano

Frederick Daniel Hardy, Two Children Studying with a Globe and Piano

 

The former Widow Barnaby tours the United States.


Trollope spent some years in the United States, first at an anti-slavery community in Tennessee, then in Cincinnati, where she tried and failed to found a profitable retail business.  She turned these failures to account in her first published work, The Domestic Manners of the Americans (1832), which established her literary reputation.  She draws again on this material in her final installment of the Widow Barnaby trilogy.

“No writer of the present day possesses a quicker perception of the ridiculous, and a keener eye for detecting the weaknesses and defects in individual or national character, than Mrs. Trollope.  To this add an almost masculine vigour of expression, and earnestness of purpose which leads her by the shortest route to the point at which she would arrive, a thorough contempt for the hypocritical conventionalities of society, and you have the key to a very remarkable literary paradox which exists with regard to this author’s works, namely, that although the majority of readers profess to dislike them, there are few contemporary writers who have acquired a greater degree of celebrity. . . .  The fact is, she studies less the prejudices of her readers than the fidelity of her pictures.  She shrinks not to paint nature as she finds it, to expose those hideous evils which rankle and fester beneath the decently disposed robes of society. . . .  Here she . . . exposes the frightful moral taint which pervades society in all the southern states where the abominable system of slavery exists.” Sunday Times, August 13, 1843

We can “assure the reader of a hearty laugh at the versatile faculties of roguery wherewith the leading characters of the tale are endowed.  Mrs. Trollope is never as much at home as when dealing with the foibles of her very good friends of the ‘model republic.’  Amidst a great deal of caricature, the most judicious friends of the Americans would admit that there is much in her writings which may serve for hints of a most useful kind.” Morning Post, August 23, 1843

Download this week’s novel:

https://archive.org/details/15529587.77771.emory.edu/page/n7/mode/2up

Novel 189: Frances Milton Trollope, The Widow Barnaby (1839)

 
Frederick Daniel Hardy, The Necklace 

Frederick Daniel Hardy, The Necklace 

 

A self-assured social upstart makes her way in the world.


For Trollope, see Novels 029, 079, 138.  This is the first installment of a trilogy featuring the title character.

Readers “will be presently enchained in the interest of the tale; for Mrs. Trollope’s usual merit—that of directness of purpose, and a strong belief and interest in her own subject—does not forsake her in the present instance. . . .  The tale proceeds naturally, cheerfully, steadily, till the third volume is half over; when a harlequinade of forced combinations and improbable adventures commences. . . .  The Widow’s earlier achievements are a genuine and amusing comedy. . . . The account of her earliest exploits . . . is almost worthy of the authoress of ‘Pride and Prejudice:’ higher praise we scarcely know how to give.” Athenaeum, January 5, 1839

“To be sure the writer’s vulgarism, prejudices, and forced combination of melo-dramatic circumstances . . . mar the character of the work; but more than one of the personae dramatis, especially ‘The Widow,’ are originals, and yet truth-speaking portraits.  The localities where the story developes itself, such as Clifton, Cheltenham, are capitally sketched, with all their provincial ambitions, scandals, and shabbiness.” Monthly Review, March, 1839

Download this week’s novel:

v.1 https://archive.org/details/widowbarnaby01trolrich

v.2 https://archive.org/details/widowbarnaby02trolrich

v.3 https://archive.org/details/widowbarnaby03trolrich

Novel 187: Anne Marsh-Caldwell, The Wilmingtons (1850)

 
Sir Francis Grant, Mrs. Margaret Hick 

Sir Francis Grant, Mrs. Margaret Hick 

 

A virtuous young man loves an even more virtuous young woman, but is encumbered with a not-so-virtuous father.


Here is another novel by Marsh-Caldwell (see Novel 069), uninhibitedly moralistic, but expert in plot and character.

“Though this tale is more tedious in its preamble—more precipitous in its conclusion than can be accredited” it “contains scenes” no other author “could have written so well.  Few will be able to escape from her new story when once they have entered on it:  few will question the vitality of some of its characters, and the force of some of its situations.” Athenaeum, January 12, 1850

The characters are sketched with great talent, the incidents are described with vigour and effect, and, above all, the workings of the heart are wrought out in earnest, passionate language.” New Monthly Magazine, February, 1850

Download this week’s novel:

v.1 https://archive.org/details/wilmingtonsnovel01mars

v.2 https://archive.org/details/wilmingtonsnovel02mars

v.2 https://archive.org/details/wilmingtonsnovel03mars

Novel 185: Cecil Maxwell, A Story of Three Sisters (1874)

 
Sir William Blake Richmond - The Sisters.jpg
 

Sir William Blake Richmond, The Sisters


Three middle-class sisters grow up and find various fates.


Nothing is known about Cecil Maxwell, except that she (he?) wrote this one novel—a very good one, on the whole. All through its beginning and middle it is excellent in its kind, with complex, well-defined characters placed in interesting situations.  Its end is marred by the sort of lover’s-misunderstanding plot that mars so many Victorian novels—the sort of misunderstanding occasioned by the inexplicable failure of A to ask B a simple yes/no question. But if you accept the premise that anybody might ever act that way, even the ending, though sad, isn’t bad.

“We cannot now do justice to the spirit and verve of ‘A Story of Three Sisters.’  It is full of brightness and colour.  It is a poet’s novel. . . .  The writer . . . is a very close observer of character and motives.” Westminster Review, January 1875

“This is a well-written story of common-place life, without much incident and without any exaggeration; it is carefully studied and well disseminated.” British Quarterly Review, January 1875

“The charming Story of Three Sisters owes . . . much of its attraction to a pure and graceful style. . . .  The characters . . . are drawn with tender care and feeling. . . .  It is rare to find so nearly perfect . . . a story . . . , which is one to linger over, and return to with a sort of nostalgie.”  Academy, January 30, 1874

Download this week’s novel:

v.1 http://access.bl.uk/item/viewer/ark:/81055/vdc_000000043BF0#?c=0&m=0&s=0&cv=8&xywh=-492%2C0%2C3639%2C1973

v.2 http://access.bl.uk/item/viewer/ark:/81055/vdc_000000043BF6#?c=0&m=0&s=0&cv=6&xywh=-488%2C0%2C3618%2C1962