David Alfred Bywaters's Crossword Cavalcade & Fortnightly Victorian Novel Recommender. Every Saturday! Either a new language-torturing puzzle or an old novel by an unjustly neglected Victorian author. Why waste time on other amusements?

Novel 010: Anonymous, Eva Desmond; or, Mutation (1858)

Arthur Hughes, A Passing Cloud
Arthur Hughes, A Passing Cloud

A virtuous but poor young lady falls in love with a man whose family wants him to marry money.


Nothing is known about the author of this novel which, with a large cast of lively characters and much circumstantial detail, tells a story of what might be called Providential revenge.

“There is a certain air of actual life, marks of observation, traces of personal experience and investigation, and a power of pourtraying things and people . . . which would have been graphic were it not for the dream-like air of unreality."  Athenaeum, September 18, 1858

The novel has a “felicitous closeness of observation, and a fluency as well as vigour of style.”  Spectator, September 25, 1858

“A work of uncommon merit.  Its construction is admirable; for, although the story is intricate” and each of its “vast crowd of personages is made to preserve...a distinct...personality,” still “the reader is never suffered to lose sight of . . . the central object of the plot, the heroine of the story.”  Critic, September 25, 1858

"Among recent fictions we know of none having a stronger claim on our commendation . . . for a freshness and sweetness that breathe of the heather of the Irish mountains.  We know not that we have ever made acquaintance in the realms of fiction with a more truly fascinating person” than Eva Desmond.  Eclectic Review, November, 1858

Download this week’s novel here:

v.1     https://archive.org/details/evadesmondormut00desmgoog

v. 2    https://archive.org/details/evadesmondormut01desmgoog

v.3     https://archive.org/details/evadesmondormut02desmgoog